Seven American Presidents held membership in the Fraternal Order of Eagles:

• Theodore R. Roosevelt – Cheyenne, Wyoming, 26th President
• Warren G. Harding – Marion, Ohio, 29th President
• Franklin D. Roosevelt – Buffalo, New York, 32nd President
• Harry S. Truman – Independence, Missouri, 33rd president
• John F. Kennedy – Hyde Park, Massachusetts, 35th President
• James Earl “Jimmy” Carter – Atlanta, Georgia, 39th President, Eagles Honorary Lifetime Member
• Ronald W. Reagan – Santa Barbara, California, 40th President, Eagles Honorary Lifetime Member